I’m not talking strictly about ideas, I’m talking about a human having a vision, and taking action to make that vision into something. Whether something is copyrightable requires a “human element,” which is the reasoning behind why machine or animal generated content cannot be copyrighted, because they lack that.
So the question is if someone tweaking an image, even if they’re merely selecting things, then is that a sufficient human element to say that a person had enough hand in creating it?
When it comes to selection, we already have a valid form of copyright which is explicitly that- compositions. If I take a bunch of royalty-free songs, and make a book of sheet music where I hand selected songs to be in that book, I can own a copyright on the composition without owning any of the featured material.
So, if someone selects a bunch of individual elements in an image using img2img, is that now a composition?
I accidentally submitted early, but also, I wrote out the lyrics. It’s the most bland version of those breakup-depression kind of songs imaginable. I guess people voted it as “feel-good” out of irony.
Sitting at my favorite cafe
Sipping my tea it’s saturday
Thinking about all he’s done, to everyone
This town is full of broken dreams
Shattered hopes, and silent screams
Somebody please help me
Betrayed by this town
Let’s tear it all down
We’re all just destined to fall
I’ve lost it all
Betrayed by this town
Let’s tear it all down
We’re all just destined to fall
We’ve lost it all
Alone in the streets, alone in my thoughts
Thinking of all our favorite spots
I thought someday things might turn around
But I was lost and never found
Betrayed by this town
Let’s tear it all down
We’re all just destined to fall
I’ve lost it all
Betrayed by this town
Let’s tear it all down
We’re all just destined to fall
We’ve lost it all
Faces painted with smiles
Lies are told
A facade of unity
A vitality sold
So I sit here in silence
Just wondering how
To rewrite the tales
This town won’t allow
Betrayed by this town
Let’s tear it all down
We’re all just destined to fall
I’ve lost it all
Betrayed by this town
Let’s tear it all down
We’re all just destined to fall
We’ve lost it all
I’ve lost it all
We’ve lost it all
I have a feeling they knew how this would be received considering it seems like they’re rage-baiting and acting pretentious to try and get attention.
Some AI generated images can require a lot of tweaking to get a final result. For example, someone might have a workflow that involves generating several images, then picking one as a base. They then take that base, and use img2img to rework certain parts to suit a vision before applying a set of post-processing effects in a traditional editor.
Or, they generate an image and use it as a base for some sort of more traditional art, or use AI generated elements in a work that is otherwise drawn traditionally.
There’s a lot of grey where I think just dismissing any creative vision is doing disrespect to the person that wanted to make something out of that vision, and put in a good amount of work outside just proompting and taking the first image that looked okay.
One of my favorite search ads that appeared in the mid 2000s happened when I was bored. I searched “grandpa” without any context just to see what would come up, because I really was that bored. One of the ads that appeared was one of those where they just shove your search in the title verbatim so someone not paying attention might think it was what they wanted.
It said something like “Looking for grandpa? Find great deals here!” I don’t remember exactly what the second part said, but the “Looking for grandpa?” part made me bust out laughing. I then started searching other random stuff to try and get something equally stupid, but it didn’t capture me quite the same way. Either way, my boredom was alleviated.
I don’t run a directly customer facing department anymore, but when I ran electronics I got to be both the employee that didn’t know much, and the one that tells you more than you asked for.
I went to college for network admin, but never actually landed a career in it because COVID hit right after I graduated. I’ve done a bit of everything with computers and can speak to a lot of things.
But I haven’t used every electronic device we sold or have even basic knowledge of some of them, so I had to fall back on “Well, a lot of people buy this one, so there’s probably something nice happening there.”
I always think the revelation types that think they’re definitely getting saved before the apocalypse is funny. The Bible says 144,000 will be saved, but the current estimate of Christians on earth is about 2.2 billion from what I can find. So you just gotta hit that 0.006545% chance.
While they’re at it, they can go to the casino, bet their entire life savings on a single number on the roulette wheel, do that twice in a row, and their odds of winning that are 11x higher than being picked for rapture.
I like how for all the problems Brazil has, the consumer protection laws are consistently some of the best around.
Unless the original standard agrees and implements it, then you’ve just created a new standard.
Man, I already had a hard time justifying my YouTube Premium subscription. I literally only have it for putting on stuff to sleep to on my TV without some ad telling me Mr. Beast wants to give me $10,000 if i click.
But the worse this gets, the more I feel like an asshole for giving them a dime.
Indie games are the only thing keeping gaming alive for me, for the most part. All the AAA games I play are older titles. Doing the GTAV story with a trainer has been a pretty fun time lately for me.
Yeah whoops, brain said terabyte but fingers said gigabyte.
I know storage is cheap, but nearly half a terabyte? I’m already giving any game the side eye if it takes more than 50G of space on a disk, let alone nearly 10x that.
The tech is interesting and has applications
I used to say that, but I’ve given up on that idea. I’ve never seen a use of blockchain yet that didn’t boil down to being virtual money. NFTs could have had potential as a method of trade if they were tied to real ownership of things instead of just receipts saying you bought a cartoon monkey jpeg.
But every time I think something would be a problem blockchain solves, I can always think of an existing, typically better, solution to that same problem. I think that space is too infested with grifters to attract anyone with a truly novel idea.
My dad went over the bars of a dirtbike when he was about 20 and landed hard on his shoulder, but walked it off.
Came back to haunt him with a vengeance last year almost 50 years later, super high pain in that shoulder that took a surgery to go away.
She would probably be touched if you asked her. I say go for it.
Political memes are just the non-grandma version of political cartoons.
Even though the limitation on TPM is completely arbitrary, and anyone sufficiently savvy can bypass it in a few ways.
But most people are not that, so I guess the Linux crowd will embrace all those computers with open arms.