• 0 Posts
  • 29 Comments
Joined 2 years ago
cake
Cake day: June 19th, 2023

help-circle


  • rah@feddit.uktoWorld News@lemmy.ml*Permanently Deleted*
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    13
    arrow-down
    3
    ·
    edit-2
    6 months ago

    The “guy” is a Russian expert and former CIA on the … Russia desk.

    Assuming that’s true then he’s a Russian expert and former CIA [officer?] on the Russia desk who’s written an article full of non sequiturs, supposition and just plain nonsense. He’s a Russian expert and former CIA officer on the Russia desk who’s a deluded fool.

    But you probably have no clue what that actually means, do you?!

    It means the embarassment from having written this article is even greater?













  • here’s the pretty unanimous “tankie” line on that question

    “This essay is presenting a very one-sided depiction of socialist states, with a great many of their shortcomings, mistakes, failures, and crimes (yes, a few) omitted or barely discussed”

    Their many shortcomings, mistakes, failures and crimes (more than a few) are why I have a disinterest in engaging with these political movements.






  • prosocial behavior in humans

    I’ll just cut-and-paste from another comment:

    “Human beings must necessarily cooperate and aid each other in order to survive. It’s how our species evolved. However, that doesn’t mean humans only ever aid each other, or even that they care about others except as a means to survive. Humans will cooperate when it’s beneficial and also stab their fellow humans in the back, step on them and exploit them when it’s beneficial. That’s why all we have are systems of elites and peasants, filled with squalor and death.”

    differing levels of exploitation

    And yet never an absence of exploitation.

    So not sure what your point is.

    That humans in general, including fellow labourers, are what are reckless of the health and life of the labourer, not just “capital”. You’re deluding yourself by limiting your criticism to capital alone. Or even worse, deluding yourself by assigning blame to capital alone.